REVIEW: Why You Should SKIP One of the Prettiest Treats at Mickey's Not-So-Scary Halloween Party in Disney World

We’ve been trying lots of spooky snacks at Mickey’s Not-So-Scary Halloween Party, but we’re not about to stop now. It’s time for DESSERT!

Mickey!

The Halloween party of the year has OFFICIALLY begun in Magic Kingdom, bringing an exclusive “Boo to You” parade, themed fireworks, and more to the park for the occasion. Come with us now to try a couple of exclusive desserts at Main Street Plaza Ice Cream Parlor!

Mickey’s Not-So-Scary Halloween Party is a seasonal Magic Kingdom event requiring a separate ticket for entry. In 2023, the event will take place on select nights from August 11th through November 1st. Although there are some Halloween treats available all day long in Magic Kingdom, others only come out for the party.

Click here to see ALL the Fall and Halloween Treats coming to Magic Kingdom.

Right now, we’re heading to Main Street Plaza Ice Cream Parlor to try out the Apple Fritter Sundae and Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich!

Main Street Ice Cream Parlor

The Apple Fritter Sundae features apple fritters topped with your choice of ice cream, whipped cream, and sprinkles and costs $8.29. We chose to get pumpkin ice cream as our flavor to stick with the fall theme of the treat.

Need a cool treat? Here’s the Apple Fritter sundae (sensing a theme this year?)! It’s Apple fritters topped with ice cream, whipped cream, and sprinkles! Simple!

?Plaza Ice Cream Parlor pic.twitter.com/CvC5aHpOIb

— Disney Food Blog (@DisneyFoodBlog) August 11, 2023

The ice cream was thick and creamy and had a nice pumpkin flavor. The apple fritters on top are a decent size and have a nice apple pie-spiced flavor to add to the treat. You get two huge scoops of ice cream on this sundae making it easily sharable. The caramel sauce on top was very sweet and we think it might be too sweet for some.

Apple Fritter Sundae

If you love apple flavor or are in a big group, this might be for you. It does melt fast in the Florida heat though so you’ll want to eat up fast.

Dig in

Next, we tried the Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich is two cookies topped with sprinkles with your choice of ice cream in the middle, and it costs $7.29. For this item, we chose cookies ‘n’ cream ice cream. Again, the ice cream was smooth and creamy and had a great flavor.

Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich

The downfall of this treat was the chocolate cookies. Unfortunately, these were HARD to bite and chew. They also were bland and only really help provide structure to the sandwich. We really recommend skipping this one and grabbing one of the other sweet treats at the party instead.

Cookies were hard and dry

There’s more where that treat came from, though! Make sure to check out ALL of the treats available at the party before you go.

Click here to see photos and reviews of ALL the Halloween treats in Disney World!

Don’t want to pay extra for treats at Mickey’s Not-So-Scary Halloween Party? Don’t worry — you can skip the restaurants and just trick-or-treat around the park instead. The candy is your typical Halloween goodies, but hey — it’s all sugar, right?

Click here for a FULL LIST of trick-or-treating stops!

If you’re heading to the party soon, you might need a SPOOKY new t-shirt to wear! We’ve got just the thing at our online DFB store.

Gather round all ye witches!

Stay tuned to Disney Food Blog for more coverage of Mickey’s Not-So-Scary Halloween Party in Disney World!

Learn more about Mickey’s Not-So-Scary Halloween Party by clicking here.

IT'S SPOOK-TACULAR!

Get ready for the spookiest season of the year at Disney World with our guide -- Halloween at Disney World: DFB's Spook-tacular Guide!

From the thrills of Mickey's Not-So-Scary Halloween Party to the enchanting resort decorations that'll send shivers down your spine, our guide is packed with tips and tricks to help you squeeze every ounce of ghoulish fun out of your visit. Plus, we've got the inside scoop on all the limited-time-only bone-chilling activities happening across the parks!

Get the Halloween at Disney World: DFB's Spook-tacular Guide to make your frightfully delightful adventure even more magical!